Home » Featured »Sunday Poll » Currently Reading:

Poll: Was The City’s Switch To Gmail A Good Or Bad Decision?

July 1, 2012 Featured, Sunday Poll 14 Comments

Last month the City of St. Louis changed their email accounts so they’re now hosted by Google’s Gmail service at a cost of $275,000.  Why?

This spring, a city department head admitted he sent an email from his work account urging acquaintances to attend a $500-a-head golf tournament benefiting the campaign of his boss, Mayor Francis Slay. (St. Louis goes Google, ends ‘archaic’ email system)

In short the system the city had used for years had virtually no tracking information. When the above email was sent the holes in the city’s 20th century email system became apparent. Also:

Employees complained that their old service did not work well with mobile devices and computers outside of the network. Now, in an effort to fix the system and cut costs they have switched to Google’s cloud based service. (St. Louis City Switches To GMail)

What do you think? Good decision? Bad decision? Comment below and vote in the poll (right sidebar) now until Sunday July 8, 2012. Final results to be published Wednesday July 11, 2012.

— Steve Patterson

  • Woodsba

    My thinking is that any improvement on better communications within a company, organization and yes, government is a good thing. In light of the fundraising email, if the new system puts a stop to this sort of thing then great.

  • Pauleisen

    I’ve used Gmail for business. It is intuitive, good for mobile, and extremely easy to manage. Will save the city in long term tech support costs, I have no doubt.

  • If you can’t check email from your home computer or mobile device, that would be a big problem. However, I would think the system would have to be extremely old for that to be true. I have not seen an email address I could not set up on an iphone, for example. Of course, tracking is an important issue too. If the system was that old, it needed to go.

  • Guest

    Steve – I love you, but you’re trying to tie together a cause and effect without enough data. Unless you know what the city spent on IT cost to manage and maintain its email servers as opposed to these cost, anyone that answers “Bad” is doing so with a major lack of information. What if by making this switch the city saved money on their IT budget and thus that money can be used other places, such as what you police/fire (now who would complain about that)? If you have that information it would be beneficial.

  • RyleyinSTL

    My impression is that the city made a good move here. Running your own Exchange server (or similar) is less and less worth it these days.  You need to worry about security updates, service packs, active directory nightmares, SPAM, viruses and a pile of other issues. All good reasons to have email hosted externally.  Additionally, if the city was in the position where they needed to update an outdated setup (which it sounds as if they were), this would have presented even greater value.  

    • RyleyinSTL

      Just finished reading some more on this. Sounds like they had an old Groupwise setup….yikes!

  • David O’Leary

    The price seems awfully steep considering Google lets small-ish companies do it for free. But in the end, moving email to the cloud makes a lot of sense.

    • RyleyinSTL

      Google has trimmed back the free service from 50 to 10 users. The price/month is competitive for the number of users and features the city is using (based on the new piece). It’s possible that the migration could have been done for less with existing IT personal but that would depend on many factors, of which, the city would know best.

  • Jeff Abernathy

    The largest cost of this contract is the data retention. I think perhaps we could have saved money by doing a lower retention, perhaps of 2 years instead of 10

  • Crosslina

    I remember participating in a survey of city administration services performed by FOCUS STL back when Harmon was mayor. They were virtually uncomputerized in even the biggest departments like permits. And they still printed their own business cards and letterhead in the basement of city hall! So I am all for bringing city government out of the dark ages and into the modern world. The name of the game today is quick communication and accurate data. City government needs it as well and initial costs can be at least partially ameliorated by saved people hours.

  • Crosslina

    Jeff, since I frequently work with federal funds I can say that many documents including types of correspondence need to be retained for at least 7 years. Then there is the case of needing to develop a case for a “pattern” of behavior that is erroneous, discriminaory etc and that can take place over a period of years. So I say that in this case it is better to be safe than sorry. – Anna

Comment on this Article:







Advertisement



Recent Comments

FACEBOOK POSTS

UrbanReview ST LOUIS shared East-West Gateway Council of Governments's photo. ... See MoreSee Less

Comments wanted on the Coordinated Human Services Transportation Plan: The Coordinated Human Services Transportation Plan considers existing transportation services for elderly and disabled individuals in the St. Louis Region, identifies gaps in current services and develops strategies to address them. The priorities identified in the plan help to determine what projects, services and initiatives will be funded across the region. A public open house will be held in East-West Gateway’s offices at One S. Memorial Drive, Suite 1600, St. Louis, MO 63102 on May 26 from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m. Find the plan and comment on-line at www.ewgateway.org until June 13.

13 hours ago  ·  

D'oh -- sometimes impatient motorists learn the hard way why construction cones are up! ... See MoreSee Less

Richardson Rd an hour ago...... they put cones up for a reason. Get this lady a 99.1 JOY sticker!

14 hours ago  ·  

If you're a registered voter in Missouri you've got one last chance to sign the petition to get medical Cannabis on the ballot. ... See MoreSee Less

St. Louis Notary Happy Hour

May 5, 2016, 4:00pm - May 5, 2016, 7:00pm

Please join us from 4-7 PM at the Schlafly Bottleworks Schlafly Bottleworks, 7260 Southwest Ave, St. Louis, MO 63143 This our LAST Notary Happy Hour in St. Louis! If you have been gathering signatures, come by and have your sheets notarized and turned in. Invite your friends and we hope to see you there!

15 hours ago  ·  

Wash Ave is closed to vehicle traffic between Tucker & 14th for Cinco de Mayo festivities ... See MoreSee Less

15 hours ago  ·  

Archives

Categories

Advertisement


Subscribe