Today two board bills were passed perfected by the St. Louis Board of Aldermen related to a section of Forest Park. The area located between Kingshighway and Euclid has been under lease by BJC since the 1970s for use as an underground parking garage. Above the garage is a green park with mature trees, racquetball courts, a playground and tennis courts. If the new proposal is approved by the city’s Board of Estimate & Apportionment BJC will be granted the rights to develop what is now a park.
Citizens opposed to the plan have obtained the signatures required to require a citizen vote whenever leasing or selling park land. Today’s vote is an attempt to get this deal done prior to the citizen vote in April to consider such a requirement.
The usual 29 members (28 Aldermen + President of the Board of Aldermen) is only 28 these days since 19th Ward Alderman Mike McMillan resigned to assume his new role as the city’s License Collector. Only two voted against the deal — Board President Jim Shrewbury and Jeffrey Boyd (D-22).
Four Aldermen were either absent from the meeting or abstained from voting on the bills related to this lease: Charles Quincy Troupe (D-1), Jennifer Florida (D-15), Terry Kennedy (D-18) and Frank Williamson (D-26). Update #2 1/26/07 5pm — Troupe & Florida were not present for the meeting today. Kennedy & Williamson, although present for the meeting, were not present for this particular vote.
The following aldermen voted in favor of the bill(s):
- Dionne Flowers, (D-2)
- Freeman Bosley, (D-3)
- O.L. Shelton, (D-4)
- April Ford Griffin, (D-5)
- Lewis Reed, (D-6)
- Phyllis Young, (D-7)
- Stephen Conway, (D-8)
- Kenneth Ortmann, (D-9)
- Joseph Vollmer, (D-10)
- Matt Villa, (D-11)
- Fred Heitert, (R-12)
- Alfred Wessels, (D-13)
- Stephen Gregali, (D-14)
- Donna Baringer, (D-16)
- Joseph Roddy, (D-17)
- Craig Schmid, (D-20)
- Bennice Jones-King, (D-21)
- Kathleen Hanrahan, (D-23)
- William Waterhouse, (D-24)
- Dorothy Kirner, (D-25)
- Gregory Carter, (D-27)
- Lyda Krewson, (D-28)
Update: [The bills will come up again next week for final approval. If approved,] the Board of Estimate and Apportionment (E&A) will determine if this deal goes through. The three members are Mayor Francis Slay, President Jim Shrewsbury and Comptroller Darlene Green. Slay has announced he will support the deal while Shrewsbury has indicated he will not (and judging by his no vote today I think it would be odd to flip flop). So, this puts the decision of the park in the hands of one person — Darlene Green. Right now she holds all the cards so I’m guessing there are some backroom conversations and deals being hatched right now. The old what will it take to get your vote?
If Green supports the plan she will be upsetting voters who have worked to place the issue on the ballot. If she votes against the plan she risks getting shut out of the political establishment backing the deal. From my perspective, Green can’t help but play politics somewhat but I think she tends to come down on the side of good fiscal policy. The question becomes, is this deal now good enough in her mind?
Last week her office sent out the following statement:
The comptroller believes people on both sides of this issue have strong points. On one side are the citizens and taxpayers who want to protect their parks and have a say in plans to develop park land. On the other side is the city’s largest medical facility that serves thousands of disadvantaged residents each year and is an economic engine for the community.
The comptroller intends to move forward in an effort to bridge the gap on these two very valid viewpoints and hopefully reach a compromise solution. She is working now to hold meetings beginning next week with both sides that focus on common ground and building consensus instead of rehashing differences. This issue is too important to our community on a number of levels for us to settle for anything less than a mutual agreement.
“The comptroller is reserving comment on the new lease plan revealed today until after these meetings and, hopefully, a compromise is reached.
I just asked the Comproller’s office if they have a new statement in light of today’s vote — I’ll let you know when they respond.
The next debate is if this will, or will not, affect the upcoming race between incumbent Jim Shrewsbury and challenger Lewis Reed. Shrewsbury is opposing the current lease while Reed supported it.
NOTE: I updated this post roughly 30 minutes after originally posting. I had indicated the bills had passed when in fact they had only been “perfected.” They will be brought up again next week for final passage. I adjusted a bit of the above language to reflect this as well as adjusting the headline.